1. Text: | Print|

      Whose sovereignty over Xisha Islands?(2)

      2014-05-19 09:05 China Daily Web Editor: Wang Fan
      1

      The sovereignty question

      The question as to who has sovereignty over the Xisha Islands is at the heart of the current situation. If Vietnam had sovereignty over the islands, there would be no dispute. However, despite much global commentary suggesting that Vietnam has a case to support its sovereignty claim, closer analysis of the history of the dispute suggests otherwise.

      Vietnam's current claim is seriously weakened by North Vietnam's recognition of Chinese sovereignty over the Xisha Islands in 1958 and its lack of protest between 1958 and 1975. A number of governments, including the United States, have explicitly or implicitly recognized Chinese sovereignty over some or all of the islands. China has occupied Yongxing Island since the end of World War Two. North Vietnamese occupation of that large feature may have significantly affected American operations against North Vietnam during the Vietnam War.

      The US has urged the claimant countries to exercise care and restraint. Against the historical background of American acceptance of China's sovereignty over Yongxing Island, it would be hypocritical now for Washington to make any stronger statement that might be seen as supportive of Vietnam's position.

      Where to now?

      Previous incidents around the Xisha Islands mainly related to fisheries management issues and China's arrest of Vietnamese fishing vessels attempting to fish in or near the islands. Undoubtedly Vietnam can make a strong case that its fishermen have traditionally fished in these waters - in much the same way as China claims traditional rights for its fishermen elsewhere in the South China Sea.

      Vietnam may well have been better off to agree to China's sovereignty over the Xisha Islands in return for China conceding traditional fishing rights in the area to Vietnamese fishermen and agreeing to pursue the joint development of marine resources in the waters between the islands and the coast of Vietnam. Unfortunately, however, the two countries have probably passed the point of no return in being able to reach such a negotiated settlement. Vietnam is playing for high odds by endeavouring to muster global and regional support for its position when in fact, it may end up with nothing.

      Hard line positions by all the parties to the sovereignty disputes in the South China Sea are short-sighted and will inevitably lead to increased tensions and regional instability. There will be 'losers' in this approach when potentially all could be 'winners' if the parties accepted the need for functional cooperation in managing the sea and its resources. The geographical reality is that straight line maritime boundaries will be impossible to achieve in some parts of the sea, and as a consequence, the sole ownership of resources will also not be possible.

      The irony of the current situation is that functional cooperation is not just something that would be nice to have but is an actual obligation under Part IX of UNCLOS covering semi-enclosed waters such as the South China Sea. That obligation has been forgotten while countries continue to assert their unilateral sovereignty claims and risk a 'win-lose' outcome.

      Sam Bateman is a Senior Fellow in the Maritime Security Program at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), Nanyang Technological University. He is a former Australian naval commodore with research interests in regimes for good order at. Rsis Analysis originally published in Lianhe Zaobao

      Comments (0)
      Most popular in 24h
        Archived Content
      Media partners:

      Copyright ©1999-2018 Chinanews.com. All rights reserved.
      Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.

      主站蜘蛛池模板: 成年女人午夜毛片免费视频| 久久精品免费观看| 国产老女人精品免费视频| 亚洲国产精品一区二区久| 色播精品免费小视频| 亚洲黄色在线观看视频| 69视频免费观看l| 亚洲人成网站在线观看播放动漫 | 91久久精品国产免费一区| 亚洲爱情岛论坛永久| 99国产精品视频免费观看| 亚洲色大成网站www永久| 久久精品免费全国观看国产| 亚洲va久久久久| 国产中文字幕免费观看| rh男男车车的车车免费网站| 国产精品亚洲二区在线观看| 中文字幕免费不卡二区| 亚洲综合色丁香麻豆| 成人免费网站在线观看| 免费国产va在线观看| 久久亚洲国产中v天仙www| 亚洲人成免费电影| 亚洲乱码无人区卡1卡2卡3| 国产在线播放免费| 中国一级全黄的免费观看| 91亚洲精品视频| 日韩在线看片免费人成视频播放| 一本久久免费视频| 久久亚洲精品国产精品| 久久精品无码一区二区三区免费 | 国产免费131美女视频| 国产精品九九久久免费视频| 久久国产亚洲精品无码| 日韩免费三级电影| 女人体1963午夜免费视频| 亚洲欧美中文日韩视频| 国产AV无码专区亚洲AWWW| 日韩免费精品视频| 久久www免费人成看国产片| 亚洲国产品综合人成综合网站|